Objective

The objective of this project was to design a cleaning tool test device to support a future effort centered on quantification of the impact of cleaning tools on antifouling paint systems, especially in terms of coating damage/service life and external inputs (e.g. biocide release). The envisioned method would require both a relevant test device (the subject of this work) and standardized processes/methods. The near-term application of the tool is evaluation of the impact of cleaning tools currently specified by the U.S. Navy (primarily motor-driven rotating brush heads) to Navy qualified and emerging biofouling-control coating systems, including both coating thickness change and external inputs (Cu and Zn release). See ESTCP project WP18-5194.

Technical Approach

In support of tool design, the project team worked with contract personnel who routinely clean U.S. Navy ships to characterize the operations of the in-water cleaning tools most often used by the U.S. Navy: SCAMPTM and a hand-held cleaning tool. This included estimating typical clamping forces and brush compression, rate of rotation of brushes, and transit speeds or residence times.

The project team then provided an experienced engineering team (Battelle), with whom they had worked with before and on related tools and issues, the general design requirements in order to obtain a quote. The initial design targets included: a) brushes must be compressed to the same extent as observed during operation of actual cleaning tool in the field, thus generating comparable shear and normal forces on the sample, b) brushes must rotate and transit the sample at the same rate as observed during on-ship operations, c) brushes/cleaning heads must be easily removed and replaced, d) device operators must be able to easily collect water samples before and after completion of the test in order to quantify biocide release, e) the entire test device was to be designed such that it could be easily drained and refilled between evaluations, and f) the materials used in the construction of the device must be corrosion-resistant and should not introduce any chemicals into the sample water that might interfere with measurement of biocides, repellents, or other compounds or inputs associated with the paint systems being evaluated. SERDP funded Battelle to design and build what is now referred to as the Cleaning Tool Test Device.

Results

Once the government team (Naval Surface Warfare Center Carderock Division and Naval Information Warfare Center Pacific [NIWC PAC]) approved Battelle’s final design, Battelle was contracted to build, deliver, and set up/demonstrate the Cleaning Tool test Device. The tool was delivered to NIWC PAC in August 2022. The tool has performed as expected and was used successfully during the execution of project WP18-5194.

Benefits

Initially the tool will be used to establish a standard method for characterizing the impact of current Navy Fleet-relevant cleaning tools on antifouling coatings (see WP18-5194). When successful, that method will be integrated into the performance specification for below waterline coatings (MIL-PRF-24647E, Performance Specification Paint System, Anticorrosive And Antifouling, Ship Hull, April 2013). The tool/method can also be used to accelerate coating/tool development and address associated critical knowledge, data, and capability gaps associated with the in-water cleaning of antifouling coatings (external inputs, coating follow-on performance, coating aging as a function of cleaning/cleaning tool, etc). The tool also reduces risk by enabling data collection off ship. (Project Completion - 2024)

Distribution Statement A: Approved for Public Release: distribution is unlimited.